NIGERIAN LAW CLAZ

Learn the Law with M.P Daniel...

WELCOME TO NIGERIAN LAW CLAZ

LightBlog

UPDATES

17 Apr 2018

April 17, 2018

The Legal Implication of Breach of Agreement or Promise of Marriage



A Promise to Marry is an agreement. It is a legally binding contract among parties. It may be written, oral or  even inferred from conducts of parties. Where any party breaches a promise to marry, such party can be sued for damages. Damages for loss of other suitors, money spent on love, wasted years, psychological and emotional trauma, etc. 

See, Martins v. Adenugba(1946) 18 NLR 63 where it was decided thus:
“Two elements are necessary to constitute a breach of agreement or promise of marriage. First, the party jilted must prove to the satisfaction of the court that there was in fact a promise of marriage under the Matrimonial Causes Act, 1990, or under Islamic Law or under Customary Law, on the part of the other sex. Second, the party reneging has really, and as a matter of fact, failed or refused to keep to the agreement of marriage.Marriage is regarded as a very sacred institution both in our jurisprudence and in our sociology. Accordingly an agreement to enter into a marriage should leave nobody in doubt as to the real intention of the parties to enter into a marriage. A mere convivial or romantic relationship without more is not enough for a court to found an agreement to marry.”Per Tobi, JSC.(Pp. 21-22, paras. G-D)

Author: Debbywise

16 Apr 2018

April 16, 2018

Creating Agency by Necessity



The doctrine of necessitous intervention by someone who is in a legal relationship with the defendant lie in the principle of agency of necessity, where an agent went beyond his or her authority by intervening on behalf of the principal in an emergency. Because of the circumstances of necessity, particularly the impracticability of the agent communicating with the principal, the courts were prepared to treat the agent as though he or she had the necessary authority to do what was reasonably necessary to save the principal's property. If an agency of necessity was established, the agent would be reimbursed for the expense incurred in rescuing the principal's property.

An agency of necessity may be created if the following three conditions are met:
a) It is impossible for the agent to get the principal’s instruction.
b) The agent’s action is necessary, in the circumstances, in order to prevent loss to the principal to prevent them from rotting.
c) The agent must have acted in good faith.

In an urgent situation, an agent has authority to act in the best interest for the purpose of protecting his principal from losses.

In the case of Great Northern Railway Co v Swaffield,  Swaffield arranged for a horse to be transported to himself care of a railway station owned by the plaintiffs. The horse arrived at the station however Swaffield was not there to meet it. As the plaintiffs could not contact Swaffield before nightfall and had no facilities to accommodate the horse, they sent it to a livery stable.
The legal issue was whether the plaintiffs could  recover from Swaffield the amount they paid the stable for the horse's accommodation? It was held that the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in placing the horse in the stable and were entitled to recover the expenses (which were reasonable) from Swaffield.



Click to Save or and to Print this Article for free
April 16, 2018

Creating Agency by Ratification



Agency by ratification exists where one person, the agent acts on behalf of another, the principal who at the relevant time was not aware of the action of the agent but later acknowledges the action by ratifying same. By this action, he is bound to be liable to the principal as well as to take all the advantages that comes with it.
Agency by ratification can arise in any one of the following situations:
        i.            An agent who was duly appointed has exceeded his authority; or
      ii.            A person who has no authority to act acted as if he has the authority.

When one of the above said situations arise, the principal can either reject the contract or accept the contract so made. When the principal accepts and confirms such a contract, the acceptance is called ratification. Ratification may be expressed or implied.
The effect of ratification is to render the contract as binding on the principal as if the agent had been properly authorized beforehand.
The doctrine of agency by ratification can be simply illustrated thus:

If Ayo, unauthorized by Bola, with Charles, which Bola afterwards recognizes and adopts, there should be no difficulty in dealing wit it as having been originally entered into with Bola’s authority. Charles undoubtedly entered into the contract on the understanding that he was dealing with Bola, and when therefore Bola subsequently agrees  to  admit that such  was the case, Charles was precisely put  in  the situation in which he was understood to be.

This doctrine must not be confused with and must therefore be distinguished from the doctrine of undisclosed principal. This is because the law permits an undisclosed principal, on whose behalf a contract has been entered into, to be liable on the contract. The effect of ratification is equivalent to previous mandate and a person who ratifies a contract entered into on his behalf is essentially in the same position as an undisclosed principal.

Validity of Ratification
For ratification to be successfully raised, it is required that the purported act of ratification must be valid, effective and binding on the alleged principal.
To acquire these qualities, the purported ratification must fulfill or meet certain criteria. These include:

Act Must be on Behalf of the Principal: For  a  successful  establishment of act of ratification, the act of ratification can only be validly executed by the alleged principal for and on whose behalf the act was originally performed.

In FOLASHADE V ALHAJI DUROSHOLA (1961)1 ALL N.L.R. 87.
It was held, per curiam, that there could be no ratification unless  a  person purported to act as an agent and to act for a particular person.
However,    in    respect   of   contracts,   the   law   is   very   different. 

In KEIGHLEY MAXSTEAD  &  CO.  V DURRANT (1901)  A.C.  240. The
House of Lords unanimously held that a contract made by a person intending to contract on behalf of a third party, but without his authority, cannot be ratified by the third party, so as to render himself liable to sue or be sued on the contract, where the person who made the contract did not profess at the time of making it to be acting on behalf of a principal.
Existence of a Competent Principal: For an act to be rectifiable, the supposed principal must be in existence at the time the act was supposedly performed for and on his behalf. It follows that the supposed principal must be a person in law. That means he must be living or be a subsisting juristic person. 

In CALIGHARA V GIOVANNI & CO. LTD (1961)3 ALL N.L.R. 534; it was held that a company cannot ratify a contract purported to have been entered into on its behalf by the promoters prior to its incorporation.


Click to Save or and to Print this Article for free
April 16, 2018

Creating Agency by Estoppel





A person cannot be bound by a contract made on his behalf without his authority. However, if he by his words and conduct allows a third party to believe that that particular person is his agent even when he is not, and the third party relies on it to the detriment of the third party, he (principal) will be estopped or precluded from denying the existence of that person’s authority to act on his behalf.

In LUKAN V OGUNNUSI (1972)5 S.C. 40, the Supreme Court of Nigeria affirmed this when it stated that:
“When a person behaves in such a way as to lead another person to believe that he has authorized a third person to act on his behalf and that other person in such belief, enters into transaction with the third person within the scope of such ostensible authority, the first mentioned person would be estopped from denying the fact  of  the first person’s agency. It would be immaterial whether the ostensible agent had no authority whatever in fact. It  would also not matter whether the ostensible agent acted  in excess of his usual authority”.

Agency by estoppel is based on the principle of “holding out” by the principal to the third person or upon the “apparent” or “ostensible” authority of the agent.

Thus, in DIDIGUN V.R.T. BRISCOE LTD (SUPRA) OMOTESHO, J. emphasizing this element of estoppel stated that:

“In law ostensible authority gives rise to agency by estoppel. Ostensible authority is based on the doctrine of “holding out””…. The holding out may be by acts of the principal. For example, by allowing the agent to hold himself out as having authority. An important factor however, is that there must be a holding out by the principal, some acts of the principal which are capable of leading another to believe that the ostensible agent has authority”.

The classical, judicial statement of the doctrine of  agency by estoppel was made in SAUL RACCAH V STANDARD COMPANY OF NIGERIA LTD (1938) 4 W.A.C.A 162. The court observed as follows:
“…. where any person by word or conduct, represents or permits it to be represented that another person has authority to act on his behalf, he is bound by the acts of such other person with respect to anyone dealing with him as an agent on the faith of such representation,  to  the same extent as if such other person had the authority, he was so represented to have”.

It is therefore possible, from the above illustrating and  judicial authorities, to proffer a broader definition of the term “estoppel” which would eliminate the need for the secondary category of agency liability based on apparent authority. In some ways, the two  categories, (ostensible and apparent authorities) seem to cover the same area. That is, that the principal has done something or has failed to do  something  on which a reasonable third party relies upon  as granting  authority on the agent to contract on behalf of the principal. In those circumstances it is right to hold the principal bound and responsible for any resulting contract with the third party. Nevertheless, there is still reason for considering them distinctly. Some courts have distinguished them and secondly apparent authority as opposed to ostensible authority generally describes the situation in which the principal has been more active in causing his own liability.

ESSENTIAL ELEMEN TS OF AGENCY BY ESTOPPEL

a.         Representation
For a successful plea of agency by estoppel, a party must show some statement or conduct by the principal amounting to a representation that the supposed agent has the authority he has been represented to have.

In ADENIJI V JADESIMI (1976) 3 Pt. 1 OYO SHC. 142 at page 145,
Agbaje J., In this respect pointed out that:
“Where, as in this case, the appellant did not have  contract with the respondent in so far as the transaction, the subject matter for this action are concerned before the transaction was concluded between her and the first defendant it is difficult for one to say that the appellant  had by words or conduct represented or permitted to be represent to the respondent that the first defendant had authority to act on his behalf in those transaction.”
In PRESIDENT CLOTHING & CO. LTD V JOSEPH ANYANWU
(1975) 1 CCHCJ 1, a Lagos High Court held that a representation in order to amount to ostensible authority must

i)          be made by word or conduct or acts of a general nature;
ii)         be made by the principal or by sources authorized to act for him;
iii)        representation of fact.

In COLONIAL BANK AND ANOR.V JOHN CANDY AND
ANOR(1890) 15 A.C .267 , the English court of appeal held that for a statement or conduct to amount to a representation. It must be clear and unambiguous.

b.        Reliance on Representation
The party who raise the issue of estoppel must show not only that a representation was made to him but in actual fact he acted upon it. If however he did not act at all on the faith of the representation, no agency of estoppel has been created.
In FARGUHARSON BROTHERS & Co. V KING &Co.(1902)
A.C.325, Lindley L.J. said that: “The holding out must be to the particular individual who says he relied on it, or under such circumstances of publicity as to justify the inference that he knew of it and acted upon it.”

c.         Alteration of Position
For a successful plea of estoppel by representation, the claimant must show that he altered his position consequent upon the representation and to his detriment.
Therefore, if he has not altered his position at all, or has done so but has not suffered any loss or detriment thereby, or has done so but not on the faith of the representation, there is no valid agency by estoppel. The position of the law on this issue is that for a  representation  to operate as an estoppel, it must be “the proximate cause of the loss” suffered by the third party.


Generally, a party seeking the aid of estoppel must himself have acted honesty and without knowledge that the supposed agent had no authority or that he had exceeded hit authority, if that be the case. This is based on the fact that estoppel is an equitable remedy and he who comes to equity must do so with clean hands and must have acted without blemish
Click to Save or and to Print this Article for free
April 16, 2018

Creating Agency by Agreement



On of the basis of a contract, agreement is the consensus of the contracting parties to the terms and conditions of the proposed contract. The same principle applies to the formation of an agency agreement by express agreement or contract of the terms thereof. In commercial transactions, an agreement is the revelation of the intention of both the agent and the principal unequivocally to constitute such a relationship.

In AYUA V ADASU & ORS (1992)3 N.W.L.R. 598 Akanbi, JCA,
restated the law in the following statement of page 611 thus;
“In the ordinary law of Agency, the paradigm is that in which the agent and the principal agree that one should  act for the other. And the term “agency” is assigned  to  this basic principle which involves consent of both parties. It is therefore trite law that agency arises mainly from a contract or agreement between the parties express or implied”.

The basic element in this situation is a manifestation  by the principal  that the agent shall act for and on his behalf and an evidence of the agent’s acceptance of that undertaking.
On the part of the principal, there must be either an actual intention to appoint the agent or an intention inferable from his words or conduct. Where an agency relationship was set up through an agreement, such agreement must nonetheless possess all the essential pre-requisites or elements of a valid contract to be sustainable. To establish the existence of a valid contract therefore, the general rules of law of contract are applicable. These rules have been comprehensively treated in Module One. It is to be that the mere fact that a person was described as a “agent or  his relationship with another person described as “agent”  in  an agreement is not conclusive in law of such facts. Where such an agreement is by parole, proof would necessarily be essential for mere spoken words could easily be misunderstood or misinterpreted. The burden of proving the existence of such a relationship rests on the party who asserts it.

By express appointment by the principal
Generally an authority is conferred by the Principal to the Agent. If the agent exceeds this authority, then the principal will not be bound and the agent will be personally liable to the third party for breach of warranty of authority.
However the common law may extend the scope of the agent’s authority beyond this, to protect an innocent third party. The principal will then be bound to the third party, but the principal can sue the agent for overstepping his actual authority, if it’s a breach of the agency contract.

By implied appointment by the principal
The law can infer the creation of an agency by implication when a person by his words or conduct acts as if he has such authority and the principal acknowledges that he was entitled to act accordingly. Implied authority, is not specifically mentioned by contract but assumed or implied by the nature of the relationship, are presumed to be given to an agent if that authority is necessary to perform the duties or responsibilities otherwise assigned to the agent or representative.
For example where one person allows another person to order goods on his behalf and habitually pays for them, an agency may be implied. In such a case, he will be bound by the contracts as if he has expressly authorized them - Chan Yin Tee v William Jacks and Co. Where however, such an agreement is inferred, from conduct, the law demands that there must be some positive act from which such inference can be drawn.

10 Apr 2018

April 10, 2018

Authority of an Agent Under Agency



       1.       Actual Authority of an Agent
The scope of an agent’s actual authority is important. Generally,  it is only if an agent cuts within actual authority that h is able to claim an indemnity from the principal for any expenses incurred or remuneration under the agency contract with the principal.In the same vein, an agent who acts outside this actual authority may be liable to the third party for breach of the implied authority. The actual authority of an agent is determined be the agreement between the principal and the agent. It is a matter of content construction. Two types of actual authority exist.

       a.      Express Actual Authority
This is the authority, which the principal  expressly gives to  the agent.  An example is where the agent is instructed to sell a particular properly for the principal. See: ELECTRONICS LTD V AKHTER COMPUTER LTD (2001) 1/BCLC/433

       b.      Implied (or Incidential) Actual Authority
In addition to express actual authority, the agent may have  implied  actual authority. However, implied authority cannot contradict express actual authority because it is only a way of filling the gaps in the agency agreement. It is not a means of altering that agreement.

An agent may have implied authority of his principal in the following ways:
                      i.            To do things that are necessarily incidental to the  execution of  the express actual authority.
                    ii.           To undertake that which is implied from the particular circumstance of the relationship between him and the principal such as where there has been a previous course of dealings.
Such authority as is customarily enjoyed by dealings in the particular market. A custom must be uniform certain, notorious (generally known), recognized as binding and reasonable.

2. Usual Authority of an Agent
The usual authority of an agent first came up for consideration in  the  case of WATTEAN V FENWICK (1893) IQ.B.346. In that  case  F owned a hotel where he appointed a manager. It was expressly forbidden from buying goods other than mineral water and bottle of beer. It had previously owned the hotel and his name remained above the door as the licenses it ordered cigars from W, who believed he was the owner of the hotel. F was had liable for the price of the cigars.
It might be argued that W did not think H was an agent, he believed H to be the principal, so if W had not been allowed to enforce the contract against F, W would have lost nothing because he was unaware of F’s existence . against this it might be said that F’s action in allowing his agent, H, to represent himself as the principal placed W in a weakened position W had every reason to suppose that H was the original principal and this misconception was facilitated by F.
The case does not fall within the normal understanding of the doctrine of apparent authority because F made no representation to W that it was acting as F’s agent.


Also, the decision does not appear to be the same with those case where someone is appointed to a particular position and the principal is bound by actions that fall within the usual authority of an agent in that position.
Click to Save or and to Print this Article for free
April 10, 2018

Capacity to Act as Agent under the Law of Agency



Capacity of an Agent
The rules governing the capacity to be a principal are quite different from that governing the capacity to being an agent. The general rule here is that any person of age and of sound mind  may act as an agent of another person. Thus, the law permits the employment as agents of infants, drunkards, mentally ill persons, aliens and others who may be under natural or legal disability. Therefore, the competence of a person to act as an agent of another is not limited by the competence of that person to act for him in that regard.
However, in some instances, particularly in business, trades and professions, the law has placed limitations on the right to be or act as an agent. This is primarily to protect the general public from  loss  or  damage at the hands of unscrupulous, unqualified and inexperienced persons who may take advantage of the ignorance of the consuming public. The adequate understanding of this set of professionals as agents is the main objective of this unit.

Legal Practitioners
The general rule and belief is that a barrister or  solicitor is an  agent of his client in regard to a matter for which he has been briefed. The client for whom he acts as barristers or solicitor is his principal. For a person   to be legally entitled to be and to act as such agent, he or she must obtain the requisite qualification as a legal practical, be called to the Nigerian Bar and have his name enrolled in the register of the Supreme Court of Nigeria.
The capacity to be or do this is regulated by the Legal Education (consolidation, e.t.c.) Decree No.13 of 1976, as amended.  Under  this law, a person is entitled to have a qualifying certificate issued to him by the Council of Legal Education stating that he is qualified to be called to the Nigerian Bar if: He is a citizen of Nigeria. He has, except where the Council otherwise directs, successfully completed a course of practical trainings in the Nigeria Law  school for a period fixed by the Council.
A person is entitled to be called to the Nigeria Bar if, and only if:
       1.       He is a citizen of Nigeria
       2.       He produces a qualifying certificate to the Body of Benchers and
       3.       Satisfies the Body of Benchers that he is of good character.

       Once these conditions are qualified, the Body of Benchers is obliged to call him to the Nigeria Bar and             issue him with a certificate of call to the Bar. Upon being called to the Nigeria Bar, such person becomes entitled to practice as a barrister and solicitor in Nigeria, if and only if, his name appears in the roll.
A person is entitled to be an agent of another if he is a barrister or solicitor. State the conditions for qualification to practice as a barrister   or solicitor in Nigeria.

Insurance Agents and Brokers
Like the legal profession, insurance business is also regulated by a law. Section 28 of the Insurance Decree No.58 of 1991 provides in part as follows: No person shall transact business as an insurance  agent unless he is licensed in that behalf under this Decree.
An application for a license as an insurance agent  shall be made  to the Director in the prescribed form and be accompanied by the prescribed fee and such other documents as may be prescribed, from time to time. If the Director is satisfied that the applicant has satisfied the requirements as may be prescribed, he shall license the applicant as an insurance agent.
The following sets of people are not eligible to apply and may have his license cancelled if he has already obtained one.
        a)      A minor.
        b)      A person of unsound mind.
        c)       An ex-convict by a court or tribunal in the nature of a criminal appropriation of found or breach of trust.
However, the applicant may also be appointed as an insurance broker if the director is satisfied, inter alia, that the applicant has the prescribed qualifications.

Cancelation of License or Refusal of Renewal
Where the director is desirous of canceling a certificate of insurance or intends to refuse its renewal, the registered insurance broker must have, Knowingly or recklessly contravened the provisions of  this part  of the said Decree; or For the purpose of obtaining a license, made a statement which is false in a material particular; or been found guilty by a court of competent jurisdiction of fraudulent or dishonest practices including misappropriation of clients’ money
Materially misrepresented the terms and conditions of any policy or contract of insurance which he has sold to the clients or seeks  to sell to prospective clients.

Auctioneers
Generally, an auctioneer is a person who conducts a sale by auction for a client both before and of the position of an agent for the vendor i.e. the owner of the goods to be auctioned. Apart from the requirement of application and obtaining a license from the appropriate licensing authority, on the payment of any prescribed fee or such other fee as may be prescribed, no special qualification is  required by statute of one who wishes to carry on the business of or act  as an auctioneer. Such an application is made to the licensing authority for the area in which the principal office or place of business of the applicant is situate. A license may be granted to a firm or corporation. It is however an offence punishable by a fine for any person to carry on the business of or act as an auctioneer without such a license.


Click to Save or and to Print this Article for free